The new business (for P6 (UK))
Part 1 of 4
This is the Finance Act 2015 version of this article. It is relevant for candidates sitting the P6 (UK) exam in the period 1 September 2016 to 31 March 2017.
Candidates sitting P6 (UK) after 31 March 2017 should refer to the Finance Act 2016 version of this article (to be published in 2017).
This is the first of two articles on the taxation of unincorporated traders. It covers issues relating to a new business including the choice of business vehicle and the first years of trading. The second article (the existing business) looks at issues relating to a change of accounting date and the final years of a business. These articles only cover a selection of issues; there are other matters that, while not featuring in these articles, may still be the subject of a question in the exam.
The taxation of unincorporated traders is an important part of the P6 (UK) syllabus and is examined regularly. Almost all of the relevant technical rules relating to income tax and National Insurance contributions are covered in the F6 (UK) syllabus, so that there is little that is new at P6 (UK). However, these rules continue to be of vital importance – a sound knowledge of these rules will enable candidates sitting the advanced taxation paper to identify the relevant issues and taxes from the information provided, and to consider the implications of alternative courses of action.
This is not an introductory article; it is relevant to students coming to the end of their studies and finalising their preparations to sit the exam. It is intended to be read proactively – ie statements made should be confirmed as true by reference to the reader’s understanding of the rules or to a relevant study text. This approach will enable situations to be analysed from first principles rather than by reference to a rigid set of memorised planning points.
Questions in the exam are likely to be based around the commercial decisions of the taxpayer. They will require candidates to have a strong knowledge of the technical rules and an ability to apply those rules briskly and accurately. Candidates may be required to identify options that are obviously advantageous, disadvantageous or irrelevant, without preparing detailed calculations – for example, by recognising that a particular strategy relating to the use of losses would simply result in a waste of the personal allowance.
The basis of assessment
The taxable profits of an unincorporated business are determined in two stages:
Where there is a tax adjusted trading loss in a basis period, the trader’s taxable trading income for the related tax year will be zero. There will also be a loss available for offset against income and/or chargeable gains. There are two main issues that candidates need to be sure of in order to be able to calculate the potential tax saving from the offset of the losses:
Candidates must then take care to consider all of the relevant possibilities in the detail necessary to provide the advice requested.
Unincorporated trader or company?
A new business can be operated as an unincorporated entity (sole trader or partnership) or as a company. The choice will be made by reference to commercial and legal issues in addition to taking into account the tax implications of the alternative business structures. Commercial issues include the effect of the chosen business vehicle on the ability of the business to raise finance, and the possible belief that a company may be regarded as larger or more financially sound than an unincorporated business. Legal issues include the existence of limited liability.
Employ or form partnership?
Where two people are to work together in an unincorporated business it may be appropriate to consider operating as a partnership as opposed to one of them employing the other. As always, there are legal and commercial implications as well as tax issues to consider here. In particular, it should be recognised that entering into a partnership is a significant transaction due to the ability of one partner to enter into a contract that binds the other partner.
From a tax point of view, the decision requires a comparison of the tax position of an employee with that of a self-employed person. In addition, where the business is loss-making, there is also the issue that the costs of employing someone will create tax and National Insurance liabilities (despite the business not being profitable). These employment costs will, of course, increase the loss available for relief, but there may be a timing difference between obtaining relief for the loss and paying the employee taxes.
The rules governing the basis of assessment and the offset of losses are of fundamental importance in the exam. You must ensure that you can apply the rules efficiently and accurately.
Note: The unincorporated trader is considered further in:
Written by a member of the P6 examining team
The comments in this article do not amount to advice on a particular matter and should not be taken as such. No reliance should be placed on the content of this article as the basis of any decision. The authors and the ACCA expressly disclaim all liability to any person in respect of any indirect, incidental, consequential or other damages relating to the use of this article.