ACCA response to EFRAG - Exposure Draft ESRS for Certain Non-EU Undertakings in Accordance with Article 40a of the Accounting Directive.

ACCA welcomes the opportunity to provide feedback on this consultation “Exposure Draft ESRS for Certain Non-EU Undertakings in Accordance with Article 40a of the Accounting Directive”. We acknowledge and commend the significant work undertaken by EFRAG in drafting the ESRS-40a.

Overall, ACCA strongly favours an ISSB+ approach as noted in ACCAs response to EFRAG’s consultation on the amended ESRS exposure draft. We advocate for a clear building block approach with the IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards as a baseline, (whether applied mandatorily or voluntarily) and ESRS 40a outlining EU-related complimentary disclosures. This will allow for coherent reporting of decision-useful information that meets stakeholders’ needs while avoiding duplication or burdensome requirements. We also make the following additional observations:

  • The proposed ‘Mixed Approach’ creates practical challenges (including increased potential costs) for undertakings with global operations and for assurance providers, hinders the aspirational level-playing field between EU and Non-EU companies and risks significantly diminishing the comparability and hence the decision usefulness of information. Therefore, any benefits to the users of general-purpose reports applying this approach will potentially be lost.
  • We encourage further reflection as to whom the users of these Sustainability Reports are including the information they need.
  • We believe any reporting should be at the topical level, as aligned to ESRS.
  • We question the appropriateness of an EU subsidiary reporting sustainability information pertaining to the parent or group. This will require the EU subsidiary to be responsible for judgements about information disclosed in relation to the group, potentially leading to duplication or seemingly inconsistent reporting and may lack relevance to the decisions of the users of the EU subsidiary sustainability report.
  • ACCA would highlight that to enhance interoperability, at the very minimum, the joint guidance “EFRAG IFRS join interoperability guidance issued in May 2024” needs to be updated considering the modification and revision of the ESRS. Additionally, the revised document should address ESRS 40a versus ISSB disclosures.

To read our comments in full, please download the document found on this page.